Social Media ROI Part 1: Framework

6 Oct

Social Media ROI Framework

Here is a simple, five-step framework for developing a social media ROI measurement program.  Remember that not all social media initiatives will result in short-term ROI generation. It is also important to comprehend the results of programs that result in non-financial value or impact. (For a quick refresher on the difference between value and ROI read this).  Holistic measurement programs should be designed to track and measure non-financial impact as well as ROI.

1. Set measurable objectives aligned with business outcomes

Failure to begin with measurable objectives is probably the most common impediment to proper social media measurement.  A couple of award seasons ago I was a judge for a major PR campaign competition and was appalled by the low percentage of programs that actually contained measurable objectives – about 20% or so.  Your objectives should be aligned with one or more desired business outcomes.  Think through all the ways in which the social business effort will contribute toward driving the overall business forward.  Make sure the alignment is obvious and understood by all involved in program approval.

2. Link to and understand the requisite business process

In order to demonstrate ROI in social media it is necessary to link the results seen in social media with the relevant business processes they are addressing.  Social programs to date generally relate to one or more of the following business processes:

Business Process

Description

CRM Crowd-sourced help, info, recommendations, customer relationships
Research Competitive intelligence, insights, voice-of-customer, trends, feedback, reputation assessment, influencers
Marketing & Sales Ideation, product promotion, hyper-local marketing, lead generation and closure, fund raising, testing, brand attributes
Communication/PR/IR Stakeholder communication (internal and external)
Innovation/Product Development Crowd-sourced ideas, problem/opportunity identification, collaboration

For example, in a B2B company, you might try to link social media efforts with the lead generation and closure process.

New Model.pptx

For a program aimed at employee engagement, you might link social media efforts to the employee recruitment and retention business process.  For an e-Commerce company you might be able to directly link to the sales process through unique URLs or click-tracking technologies.

New Model.pptx-1

Understanding which business processes are impacted by social networks, and how, is fundamental to understanding ROI.

3. Select communications model, research approach and key metrics

In addition to understanding the business process impacted by social programs, it is important to have a communications model to assess non-financial impact.  The accepted Outputs – Outtakes – Outcomes communication model is difficult and confusing for many to understand and apply.  Here is an alternative communication model that is somewhat more intuitive and in tune with social media measurement.

  • Exposure – To what degree have we created exposure to content and message?
  • Engagement – Who is interacting/engaging with our content?  How and where?
  • Influence – The degree to which exposure and engagement have influenced perceptions and attitudes of the target audience.
  • Action – As a result of the social media effort, what actions if any has the target taken?”

Microsoft Word

The metrics listed are a starting point.  You will note these metrics come from all three “zones of measurement” – web analytics, digital content analysis and primary audience research.

Possible ROI research approaches include:

  • Correlation modeling and econometrics
  • Staff cost reduction and/or cost elimination tracking
  • Direct linkage via unique URLs and click-tracking
  • Exposed/Not-exposed primary audience research
  • Integrated cross-platform research – web analytics, content analysis, click tracking, primary research.

4. Gather and analyze data

Gather longitudinal data for the requisite business process and communications model metrics.  When attempting to show statistical correlations, the amount of data you include is important because it impacts the confidence level of the results.  Also, what metrics you attempt to correlate and how is crucial.  For example, we might try to correlate social media brand engagement and audience influence with metrics like likelihood to recommend to a friend, likelihood to seriously consider the product or likelihood to purchase the product in the next X months.  Select the metrics that are most applicable to the business process you are attempting to drive.

5. Calculate ROI and report results

We started with measurable objectives, aligned them with requisite business processes, determined our research model and approach and have gathered the data.  Now we can calculate ROI and describe the value of the social business initiative.  Results for key program metrics should be captured on a dashboard that may be shared with all program stakeholders are a regular basis.

(Note: Part two of this post will cover specific research approaches to determining social media ROI in more detail)

15 Responses to “Social Media ROI Part 1: Framework”

  1. Steven Moore October 7, 2009 at 6:43 am #

    With all the tools and things we can measure it is a great time to find the great leaders of companies that are ready to engage and innovate their companies. Thanks for the information and the way you have formatted it.

  2. metricsman October 7, 2009 at 8:23 am #

    Thanks for your comment, Steven. I’ll be on the look out for those great leaders!

  3. Sean Williams October 7, 2009 at 8:52 am #

    As always, Don, excellent framework and post. The first step of setting measurable objectives seems to be a major issue in our profession. In fact, in my practice, that’s the starting place for strategic planning. You’d be shocked at how surprised some of my clients are by that.

    There are many communicators who don’t want to attempt distilling the impact of their activities from the surrounding influences — this is particularly true when the sales cycle is lengthy. How do we know, for example, that our increased social media profile actually caused the sale? Southwest Airlines can tell because of the nature of their product, but will I buy a computer absent foreknowledge of the brand as a result of a Tweet? Unlikely, though maybe there are people who will.

    That’s why considering the impact across the dimensions you suggest is so important. Can we definitively say that our activity caused the sale? No, but we can model out its relative impact through research.

    We could use a few big research efforts that quantify the impact on purchase decisions of all of the various inputs — advertising, referrals from friends, personal experience, third-party objective endorsement, etc.

    Good stuff!
    Sean
    @commammo

  4. metricsman October 7, 2009 at 10:19 am #

    Hi Sean,
    Thanks very much for your insightful comment. Measurable objectives always seem to be more of a challenge that they should be. In my undergrad class, I can assure you every student could write a measurable objective by the end of the class. They probably grew tired of my hammering the concept into their brains.

    Understanding the impact and influences is a major challenge that may be addressed through modeling as you suggest. Last click attribution is a challenge – that is giving too much credit to the last click that resulted in a transaction and forgetting all the communications and marketing work that proceeded and perhaps enabled the ultimate sale. Modeling may be used in this context to perform value attribution of the sequential events leading to the last click.

    -Don B

  5. jacob morgan October 7, 2009 at 3:27 pm #

    Great job of putting that framework into place. We’ve definitely written about similar topics i.e. the difference between impact and ROI. I don’t think it’s enough to set objectives aligned with business outcomes; you actually need to make sure you have the processes and infrastructure in place to help you actually calculate ROI. I’ve spoken with companies that say they want to increase sales, yet when I ask them questions such as “what’s the customer purchase cycle,” they have no idea. This means that they are setting objectives and aligning them with business outcomes but they then don’t have the starting data to begin with in order to see any effect.

    Great job explaining this

  6. metricsman October 7, 2009 at 3:54 pm #

    Hi Jacob,
    Thanks for stopping by and for your comment. Fully agree with your point – you have to understand the business process you’re impacting as well as the desired business outcomes. Understanding just business outcomes is necessary but not sufficient. Thanks again, Don B

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. DR. WHAW? – October 6, 2009 « One true sentence. - October 7, 2009

    [...] Social Media ROI Part 1: Framework by Don Bartholomew — This is an invaluable resource for anyone even thinking about social [...]

  2. Social Media ROI Part 2: Research Approaches « MetricsMan - October 8, 2009

    [...] Media ROI Part 2: Research Approaches 2009 October 8 by metricsman In Part 1, we attempted to define a framework for thinking about measuring the ROI of social media activities [...]

  3. Non Stop Portals Blog » Social Media Return On Investment (ROI) - October 8, 2009

    [...] Social Media ROI Framework [...]

  4. Social Media Costs … More Than Just ROI Calculations : Natural Search Blog - October 13, 2009

    [...] more thoughts on measuring social media? Be sure check out these great posts by Don Bartholomew, Social Media ROI Part 1: Framework and Social Media ROI Part 2: Research [...]

  5. DHM’s Weekly Link Tips #1 « davidhamann media - October 15, 2009

    [...] Social Media ROI Part 1: Framework (metricsman.wordpress.com) [...]

  6. How To Measure Social Media Marketing ROI In Three Steps | Womenwise Marketing - November 16, 2009

    [...] He suggests several ways to track each method’s success. Exposure, for example, might be measured by web traffic, search engine rank and number of reader comments. Engagement can be measured by the duration of each visit and the number of return visitors. This image comes from Bartholomew’s blog post on the subject, “Social Media ROI Part 1: Framework:” [...]

  7. Play to play: Wie sich professionelle Social Media bezahlt macht - November 27, 2009

    [...] von acht Stufen des Social Media Marketing sowie Don Bartholomew in seinem Entwurf eines Social Media ROI Framework vorgestellt. Socialize [...]

  8. Social Media Kommunikation messen | Grenzpfosten - December 13, 2009

    [...] das gehen kann zeigt Don Bartholomew, der Metrics Man. Er nennt das Ganze Social Media ROI (auch der erste Teil ist sehr empfehlenswert) . Es besteht im Prinzip aus einem Raster von verschiedenen Funktionen, [...]

  9. Social Media Massnahmen messen » Social Media Führerschein - March 31, 2011

    [...] des ROI vor dem Hintergrund einiger Business Modelle, einfacher Metriken und Basis-Returns. Auch Teil 1 ist lesenswert. Ich habe hier seinen Ansatz mal [...]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 171 other followers

%d bloggers like this: